Development
and validation of stability indicating reverse phase high performance liquid
chromatographic method for estimation of Donepezil HCl from bulk drug
Yesha K. Patel*, M.N. Noolvi1, Hasumati Raj, Meghna P. Patel
Shree Dhanvantary Pharmacy College, Kim, Surat
ABSTRACT:
Stability of Donepezil
Hydrochloride(DONE) was investigated using stability indicating Reverse phase
high performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) utilizing C-18 column and
mobile phase containing Acetonitrile: Water (pH
3.5) in ratio of 40:60 at flow rate of 1
ml min-1. Peaks of donepezil and degradation products
were well resolved at retention times < 7 min. Stability was performed in
0.1N hydrochloric acid, 0.1N sodium hydroxide, 3 % hydrogen peroxide, neutral,
photolytic and dry heat conditions. Fast hydrolysis was seen in alkaline
condition as compared to oxidative and neutral conditions. Methods
was validated with respect to linearity, precision, accuracy,
specificity and robustness LOQ and LOD. It was also found to be stability
indicating, and therefore suitable for the routine analysis of Donepezil hydrochloride in the pharmaceutical formulation.
KEY WORDS:
Donepezil hydrochloride, RP- HPLC, Method
Development, Stability studies.
INTRODUCTION:
Donepezil is a reversible inhibitor of the enzyme acetylcholinesterase (AchE)
approved for use in Alzheimer’s disease.[1] The pathogenesis of Alzheimer’s disease
attributed some of them to a deficiency of cholinergic neurotransmission.
Therefore, AChE inhibitors, which prevent the hydrolysis of acetylcholine,
may exert their therapeutic effect by enhancing cholinergic function. The first
AChE inhibitor (tacrine)
has been used, however, associated with a high incidence of gastrointestinal
(GI) side effects and hepatotoxicity.[2] Donepezil
is a potent and more selective AChE inhibitor in the
central nervous system with little effect on peripheral tissue, therefore, has
a lower incidence of GI and
cardiovascular adverse effects. The drug produces modest improvements in
cognitive scores and has a long half-life allowing once daily dosing.
Donepezil is slowly absorbed from the GI tract.[3] The present work describes the
utility of RP- HPLC in forced degradation-stability study under different
chemical conditions.
EXPERIMENTAL:
Chemicals:
Donepezil HCl was gifted by Sun Pharmaceutical Pvt. Ltd. Baroda,
Gujarat
Methanol HPLC Grade (Finar)
HPLC Water
HCl AR Grade (Merck)
NaOH AR Grade (Merck)
H2O2 AR Grade (Rankem)
Potassium dihydrogen Phosphate LR Grade (Renkem)
Acetonitrile HPLC Grade (Finar)
Instrumentation:
Company : Shimadzu
Model No : SPD 10 A-LC
Software : Winchrome Softwer
Operation : Semi Automatic
Semi micro analytical balance (Sartorius
CD2250, Germany) was used for weighing purpose.
HPLC water was obtained using Arium®611VF
(Sartorius).
Magnetic stirrer (1 MLH, Remi) was used for mixing purpose.
pH tutor (313927, Eutech
Instruments) was used for pH measurement.
Sonication of solutions
were done using
Ultrasonic cleaner (D 120/1H, Trans-O-Sonic).
Nylon membrane filters (0.22 µm, 47 mm D)
All volumetric glasswares used were
calibrated.
DEGRADATION
STUDIES:
All
degradation studies were done at a drug concentration of 50µg ml-1. For acid
decomposition studies, drug was dissolved in 0.1N HCl
and solution was boiled under reflux for 1 hr. The studies in alkaline
conditions were done in 0.1N NaOH boiling under
reflux for 1 hr. For study in neutral conditions, drug in water was boiled
under reflux for 1 hr. For oxidative conditions, initial studies were done in
3% H2O2 solution. The solution was kept at room
temperature for 1 hr. Photolytic studies were done by exposing solid drug
directly to uv light for 2 hr. Thermal
decomposition studies were performed by exposing solid sample of drug to dry
heat at 70şC for 2 hr in hot air oven.
HPLC
ANALYSIS[4]
CHROMATOGRAPHIC SEPERATION:
Standard and sample solutions were injected in column. The
chromatogram was run for appropriate time duration with degassed mobile phase,
mixture of Acetonitrile: Water pH 3.5 (40:60 v/v), using UV detector (SPD-20AV) at wavelength 230
nm. The chromatogram was stopped after separation was achieved completely. Data
related to peak like area, height, retention time, resolution etc was recorded
using CLASS-VP software (version 2.31).
Chromatographic
Conditions of Developed Method:
|
Sr
no |
HPLC Conditions |
Results |
|
1 |
Elution |
Isocratic |
|
2 |
Mobile Phase |
Acetonitrile: Water pH 3.5 (40:60 v/v) |
|
3 |
Diluent |
Acetonitrile |
|
4 |
Flow Rate |
1 ml/min |
|
5 |
Detector |
UV Visible |
|
6 |
Injection volume |
20 µL |
|
7 |
Wavelength |
230 nm |
|
8 |
Column
Temperature |
Room temperature |
|
9 |
Run time |
10 min |
|
10 |
Column |
Inert Sustain SwiftTM C18 (250mm×4.6mm i.d.)
5μm |
STANDARD CHROMATOGRAM:
Blank
Donepezil HCl
Condition:
Mobile Phase: Acetonitrile:
Water pH 3.5(40:60 v/v)
|
Name |
Retention time(min) |
Theoretical Plates |
Tailing Factor |
|
Donepezil HCl |
5.08 |
8528.92 |
0.51 |
OBSERVED VALUE FOR SYSTEM SUITABILITY TEST
|
Sr No |
System SuitabilityParameter |
Donepezil HCl |
IP’2007 specification |
|
1. |
Number of Theoretical Plates (N) |
8528.92 |
>2000 |
|
2. |
Resolution |
- |
>2 |
|
3. |
Tailing Factor(Tf) |
0.51 |
<2 |
VALIDATION OF DEVELOPED RP-HPLC METHOD[5]
1) Specificity:
Specificity
was measured by injecting a blank solution and another blank solution which was
previously spiked with common excipients. No any
interference by excipients was observed. The entire
base line was found stable.
(2) Linearity Range:
The
linearity range for Donepezil HCl
was found to be 10-100 μg/ml. Correlation
co-efficient for calibration curve of Donepezil HCl (DONE) was found to be 0.998.
The
regression line equation for Donepezil HCl is as follows:
y = 25514x
+ 41169
Where,
y=corresponding peak area from CLASS VP software (v2.31)
x=
Concentration of Donepezil HCl
in μg/ml.
Chromatogram of
standard Donepezil HCl
Calibration Data and Calibration Curve:
|
Sr No. |
Donepezil HCl (μg/ml) |
Mean Area ±SD (n=6) |
|
1. |
10 |
317958 ±620 |
|
2. |
20 |
533316 ±3349 |
|
3. |
30 |
787252 ±3677 |
|
4. |
40 |
1068169 ±4172 |
|
5. |
50 |
1326223 ±2028 |
3).Precision:
Intraday Precision:
The
results for intraday precision for Donepezil HCl are presented in Table.
|
Conc. (µg/ml) |
Peak Area ±
SD (n=3) |
%RSD |
Mean % RSD |
|
10 |
318860 ± 992 |
0.31 |
0.21 |
|
30 |
787616 ± 405 |
0.05 |
|
|
50 |
1329368 ± 3805 |
0.28 |
Interday Precision:
|
Conc. (µg/ml) |
Peak Area ±
SD (n=3) |
%RSD |
Mean % RSD |
|
10 |
326043 ± 1340 |
0.41 |
0.50 |
|
30 |
801079 ± 3947 |
0.19 |
|
|
50 |
1414963 ± 13058 |
(4) Accuracy:
The data for
accuracy study for Donepezil HCl
are presented in Table. % Recovery for Donepezil HCl was found to be in range of 99.0-100.53%.
|
Conc μg/ml |
%Spiking |
Total Conc μg/ml |
Peak Area |
Recovered Amt. μg/ml |
%Recovery |
Mean %
Recovery |
|
10 |
- |
10 |
253049 |
9.91 |
99.18 |
100.29% |
|
10 |
80%(8) |
18 |
462472 |
18.12 |
100.70 |
|
|
10 |
100%(10) |
20 |
517568 |
20.28 |
101.42 |
|
|
10 |
120%(12) |
22 |
560704 |
21.97 |
99.89 |
5.
LOD and LOQ:
The data for LOD and LOQ for Donepezil
HCl are presented in Table. LOD for Donepezil HCl was
1.3527μg/ml and LOQ was 4.0993μg/ml.
|
Sr No. |
Parameter |
Donepezil
HCl |
|
1. |
S.D of the
Y-intercepts of 6 calibration curve |
41169 |
|
2. |
Mean slope of
the 6 calibration curves. |
25514 |
|
3. |
LOD = 3.3 ×
(SD/Slope) (μg/ml) |
0.85 μg/ml |
|
4. |
LOQ = 10 ×
(SD/Slope) (μg/ml) |
2.59 μg/ml |
ASSAY:
·
Twenty ‘AERICEP’ Tablets (containing 10 mg
of Donepezil HCl) were
accurately weighed and ground to fine powder.
·
An accurately weighed quantity equivalent
to 100 mg of Donepezil HCl
(DONE) from the formulation fine powder was transferred to 100 mL volumetric flask and 40-50 ml Acetonitrile is added to dissolve the drug, Sonicate for 15 mins. Volume is
made up to the mark with the Acetonitrile.
·
Filter Stock solution (100
μg/mL).
|
Sample Label |
Claim (mg) |
Concentration taken (μg/ml) |
Concentration found (μg/ml) |
% Assay |
|
Donepezil HCl |
10 mg |
30 |
31.92 |
103.40% |
7.Robustness:
|
Sr No. |
Factor |
Conc |
Level |
Mean (n=3) ±SD |
%RSD |
|
1 |
Change in flow
rate |
50µg/ml |
0.8 |
1532054 ± 6104 |
0.39 |
|
1.2 |
1332303 ±7842 |
0.53 |
|||
|
2 |
Change in wavelength |
50µg/ml |
232 |
1485170± 4023 |
0.27 |
|
228 |
1337647± 8685 |
0.64 |
Summary
of Validation Parameters:
|
Sr
No. |
Parameters |
Result |
|
1. |
Wavelength (nm) |
230 nm |
|
2. |
Linearity range
(μg/ml) |
10-50 µg/ml |
|
3. |
Standard
Regression equation |
Y=25514x + 41169 |
|
4. |
Correlation
coefficient (R2) |
0.998 |
|
5. |
Precision (%RSD)
Intraday Interday |
0.21 0.50 |
|
6. |
% Recovery
(Accuracy, n = 3) |
100.29% |
|
7. |
LOD (μg/ml) |
0.85 |
|
8. |
LOQ (μg/ml) |
2.59 |
|
9. |
Robustness a)
Flow
rate change b)
Temperature
change |
0.46 0.45 |
|
10. |
Assay (% Label
claim) |
103.46% |
FORCE DEGRADATION STUDIES [6]
(a) Acid degradation:
100 mg drug dissolve in 1 ml Acetonitrile
and dilute up 100 ml of 0.1N HCl. Pipette out 0.5 ml
and solution neutralize with equivalent amount of 0.1 N NaOH
and dilute with acetonitrile up to 10 ml .Then this
solution is kept for 1 hour at , 70˚C and peak is recorded . Sample withdrawal at 0 min,
after 10 min, 30 min, 1hr at 70˚C.
(b) Alkali degradation:
100 mg drug dissolve in 1 ml Acetonitrile
and dilute up 100 ml of 0.1N NaOH. Pipette out 0.5 ml
and solution neutralize with equivalent amount of 0.1 N HCl
and dilute with acetonitrile up to 10 ml .Then this
solution is kept for 1 hour at 70˚C and peak is recorded. Sample
withdrawal at 0 min, after 10 min, 30 min, 1hr at
70˚C.
(c) Oxidation:
3% H2O2
was taken in a 100ml volumetric flask then accurately weighed 100mg bulk
drug was dissolved in it and then volume
is made by 3 % H2O2.Then this solution is kept for 1 hr
and peak is recorded .Sample withdrawal at 0 min, after 10 min, 30 min, 1hr .
(d) Neutral Condition:
First Distilled water was taken in a 100 ml volumetric flask then
accurately weighed 100 mg bulk drug was dissolved in it.,
volume is made by Water (1000 ppm). Then this
solution is kept for 1 hour at 70˚C and peak is recorded .Sample
withdrawal at 0 min, after 10 min, 30 min, 1hr at
70˚C.
(e) Photolytic Condition:
100mg of bulk drug was put
into the petridish and placed under direct UV Light for 1 hr.10mg is weighed and make upto 10 ml, using diluent Acetonitrile
and chromatogram was recorded. Similar Procedure is followed for 2 hr.
(f) Thermal Condition:
100 mg of bulk drug
was taken in a cleaned Petridish and was
put it into the oven at 70˚C for 1 hour. 10mg of bulk drug from the
Petridish was weighed and dissolved in
10 ml of diluent Acetonitrile and chtomatogram was recorded. Similar Procedure is followed for 2hr.
ACID DEGRADATION
BASE DEGRADATION
NEUTRAL DEGRADATION
OXIDATIVE DEGRADATION
PHOTOLYTIC DEGRADATION
THERMAL DEGRADATION
SUMMARY OF
OVERALL DEGRADATION STUDY
|
Condition |
% Degradation |
|
|
After 1 hr |
After 2 hr |
|
|
Acidic |
60.05% |
- |
|
Basic |
92.31% |
- |
|
Neutral |
13.58% |
- |
|
Oxidation |
78.05% |
- |
|
Photolytic |
1.62% |
3.23% |
|
Thermal |
10.76% |
12.48% |
DISCUSSIONS:
The stability of the new donepezil hydrochloride is investigated using stability
indicating RP-HPLC procedure. The method permits detection and quantitation of donepezil
hydrochloride in the presence of its degradation products. It was subjected to
stress conditions as per ICH guidelines. The drug was found to degrade in
alkaline, oxidative and neutral conditions while it was found to be stable
under photolytic and dry heat conditions. The drug can be analyzed specifically
in the presence of different chromophoric degradation
products by using isocratic conditions and mobile phase containing Acetonitrile :
Water (pH 3.5)in the ratio of 40: 60. The method was validated for parameters
like linearity, precision, accuracy, specificity and robustness.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
Shree Dhanvantary Pharmacy College for providing facilities to
carry out this work.
REFERENCES:
1.
Jackson
S and Wilkinson D. The safety and tolerability of donepezil
in patients with Alzheimer's disease. British
J. Clinical Pharmacol. 58 (2); 2004: 1-8.
2.
Joe
GH, Perry BM and Raymond WR. Goodman Gilman’s pharmacological basis of
therapeutics. 11th Edition, Mcgraw Hill medical
publishing, New york, 2001,pp
506.
3.
Noppamas
R, Siriluk A, Nutthiya
H, Sukit R and Supanimit.
Bioequivalence Study of Donepezil Hydrochloride
Tablets in Healthy Male Volunteers. Int.
Scholarly Research Notices. 23(6); 2012: 1-4.
4.
Sethi PD
and Sethi R. HPLC: Quntitative
Analysis of Pharmaceutical Formulation, Published by CBS, 2007; 15 th ed:
pp 1-211.
5.
International
Conference on Harmonization, Harmonized Tripartite Guideline, Validation of
Analytical Procedures, Text and methodology, ICH Q2 (R1), 2005.
6.
International
Conference on Harmonization, Harmonized Tripartite Guideline, Stability Testing
of New Drug Substances and Products (Revision 2), ICH Q1A (R2), 2003.
Received on 27.02.2015 Accepted on 21.03.2015
© Asian Pharma
Press All Right Reserved
Asian J. Pharm.
Res. 5(2): April-June 2015;
Page 96-101
DOI: 10.5958/2231-5691.2015.00014.3